Should We Vouch For Vouchers?
The Pros of School
Vouchers
-
gives students in failing
schools an alternative
-
holds failling schools
accountable to improve by creating competition for their federal funding
-
creates more teaching positions
The Cons of
School Vouchers
-
takes much needed money
away from failing schools, which makes improvement virtually impossible
-
leaves the possibility
for fraud and waste as for-profit companies move into the education business
and accredidation standards slip
-
adds cost to transportation
as many students using vouchers must travel long distances to school with
the district picking up the bill

-
leads to greater segregation
of students by socioeconomic status and race as vouchers tend to benefit
more advantaged families
-
in general, evaluations
of voucher students' grades show no or only small improvements compared
to public school students