I have discovered a common
trend that occurs when people feel strongly about any given topic.
Most people are unwilling or incapable of discussing the strengths and
weaknesses of their position and the oppositions position. An example
of this is the common quote, "We can talk about anything BUT religion and
politics." I theorize that these two topics are taboo because they
are so deeply seated in our beliefs. Any discussion of these two
topics will uncover the likelihood that we haven't thoroughly thought out
our position. Most likely we adopted our positions on these topics
from our parents or what is dominant in our local society. Additionally,
now that our views have been challenged, we may have to go through the
painful process of rethinking our position, realize we were wrong or that
our position wasn't the best one, and change our thinking accordingly.
Of course, we can respond the way most people do. To say, "Don't
confuse me with the facts, my mind is already made up!" At this point
your probably thinking "what does religion and politics have to do with
school uniforms?" Nothing, other than they are extreme examples of
how people have made up their minds as to how they feel and they are unlikely
to change.
The majority of information
on the Internet in regards to school uniforms is initiated by two sources.
Teenagers who have experienced school uniform implementation and didn't
like it or, teenagers who don't like the idea of school uniforms based
upon what they've heard. The second source primarily comes from government
and educators who have done studies or have experienced school uniform
policy first hand. The second source has reported mixed results for
and against this concept and how to implement or modify it.
The important question
to ask is, "What are we trying to accomplish in our public schools and
how are we going to go about it?" This is probably a generic question
we could all agree upon, but the answers would be as varied as the number
of people responding. For the sake of being brief, I will take this
huge question and attempt to answer part of it with my views.
I believe that school
uniforms should be implemented on a large scale in a few states (statewide)
in different geographical parts of the country for a twenty-five year period.
"Woah!!", the students scream, "I think it's a terrible idea. I don't
want to wear any stupid looking clothes!" The parents likewise respond,
"Who's going to pay for all this?" I have answers to those and many
other pros and cons. I don't profess to have all the answers, but
I do know this much. School uniforms have been used nationwide in
other countries with fewer resources than we have and they have implemented
their policies without extreme sacrifice. The benefits of an improved
education for our children's future by using school uniforms would outweigh
the inconvenience. We live in, quite probably, the greatest nation
on Earth. If we can't make bold experiments and commitments to do
everything within our resources to improve our way of life, then we have
mixed up priorities. Providing ALL our children with the best education
possible is one of the keys to improving our society as a whole and should
be as important as our national defense budget. We can spend the
money through education to give every child a chance at improving their
prospects for the future or we can imprison them as adults when they make
poor choices because they had no opportunity.
There are many that
claim that students shouldn't have to wear uniforms because it takes away
their ability to make decisions for themselves. I like wearing nice
clothing just as much as the next person, and I know as a student I would
have objected to the idea of having to wear a school uniform. As
an adult though, I can see the benefits of wearing a school uniform, and
think it outweighs any inconvenience. Students would still have the
ability to make decisions on what to wear for clothing. This would
be done on their own time, after school and on weekends. Additionally,
the attention in school would be taken off "who is wearing what" and onto
"who is achieving academically". This would cause students to strive
for recognition by academics, rather than clothing.
Even if all my arguments
up to this point have been inaccurate and in vain, I propose one final
statement that can stand alone against the anti uniform crowd. A
students job is to learn and prepare themselves for a life as well rounded
and productive human beings. Like many jobs in our society, students
should be required to wear uniforms as a part of their occupation.
Soldiers wear camouflage to protect themselves from being seen by the enemy
and to bond themselves into a team. Nurses wear uniforms for pride
and to distinguish themselves from other positions so they may be easily
noticed. Firemen wear uniforms and equipment to protect themselves
from flames. Likewise, students should wear uniforms to facilitate
their learning. It comes as part of the job, it's nothing personal.
The purpose of going to school is not to look cool, but to get an education.
If wearing school uniforms is going to do away with problems and increase
learning, then it should be implemented.
![]() |
![]() |